The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt set a new standard for what players expect from an action RPG. For those who have traversed the vast lands of Temeria and are hankering for more adventures, fret not. Numerous games offer experiences wrought with moral dilemmas, nail-biting combat, and a rich narrative. From gothic landscapes to stylish JRPGs, if you're pondering what to play after Witcher 3, take a gander at this curated list. Each title is evaluated for its ability to capture some of The Witcher 3’s magic and is packed with ambition and scope, promising to whisk you away to new yet pleasantly familiar realms.

Elden Ring – A Monumental Journey Awaits

Elden Ring is the progeny of a collaboration between FromSoftware and George R.R. Martin, blending the intricate Soulsborne formula with open-world freedom. Players are thrown into the heart of an epic saga, tasked with piecing together the Great Runes and ultimately shaping the fate of the Lands Between. Explore everything from catacombs to castles as you uncover a world teeming with lore, head-scratching secrets, and relentless foes.

Pros:

• A monumental open world filled with myriads of secrets and dungeons
• Deep and challenging combat that rewards skill and strategy
• Freedom to approach obstacles and bosses in various ways

Cons:

• High difficulty curve that may deter some players
• Less emphasis on narrative compared to The Witcher 3

Assassin’s Creed Odyssey – Forge Your Own Odyssey

Assassin’s Creed Odyssey catapults players into ancient Greece, offering a tale as epic as the legends born in the era. You'll step into the sandals of a Spartan warrior embroiled in a story of bloodline and prophecy. Ubisoft’s penchant for merging historical periods with fiction shines through in Odyssey’s compelling gameplay, which includes sprawling land and sea battles. The game’s skill tree also adds a layer of depth, allowing for a tailored playstyle.

Pros:

• Massive, richly-detailed open world with historical intrigue
• A satisfying progression system allows deep character customization
• Naval combat provides a seamless blend of exploration and warfare

Cons:

• It can be overwhelming due to the sheer size and quantity of content
• Some recursive quest designs may lead to fatigue

Horizon Zero Dawn – A Lush Blend of Nature and Technology

Horizon Zero Dawn’s post-apocalyptic landscape presents a unique blend of lush environments and advanced technology. You play as Aloy, a skilled huntress on a quest to uncover her past and the mysteries of the world’s robot-dominated future. The game is renowned for its stellar narrative, compelling protagonist, and breathtaking vistas. Combat is a significant highlight, emphasizing strategic engagements with both human and robotic adversaries.

Pros:

• Engaging story with a well-defined protagonist
• Well-executed combination of primitive and futuristic elements
• Dynamic, tactical combat against awe-inspiring mechanical beasts

Cons:

• Some might find resource management to be a bit tedious
• The dialogue and side missions might not match up to the main narrative's excellence

Kingdom Come: Deliverance – Realism in Role-Playing

Kingdom Come: Deliverance immerses players in the gritty reality of the Holy Roman Empire’s feudal system. The game’s meticulous attention to historical detail sets it apart, providing an RPG experience like no other. You'll find yourself navigating a world where every decision counts, from social interactions to the weighty consequences of your actions, and combat demands patience and precision in a bid for realism seldom seen in the genre.

Pros:

• Intricate and realistic medieval combat system
• High level of immersion through historical accuracy and detail
• The impacts of player’s choices feel significant and consequential

Cons:

• The steep learning curve with its realism-based systems
• Technical issues can occasionally hamper enjoyment

Divinity: Original Sin 2 – A Masterclass in RPG Mechanics

Divinity: Original Sin 2 serves as a top-tier example of mechanics driving the narrative as they intertwine with deep, tactical combat and expansive freedom within its world. This game is a haven for creative problem solvers, offering an array of spells and abilities that can be combined to devastating or innovative effects. Whether you’re seeking to resolve conflicts or plunge into them, Divinity provides an array of options at every turn.

Pros:

• Unmatched freedom in character creation and development
• Cleverly designed turn-based combat system that rewards creativity
• Exceptional multiplayer experience with coop gameplay

Cons:

• Text-heavy with a complex plot that might overwhelm some players
• It can be not easy, especially for newcomers to the genre

Conclusion – Journey Onward to Your Next Adventure

Whether you're captivated by the call of distant lands in Elden Ring, seeking the tumultuous seas of Assassin's Creed Odyssey, or simply yearning for the narrative brilliance of Divinity: Original Sin 2, each game mentioned has its unique virtues. Based on user reviews, the best action RPG to play if you like The Witcher 3 is Divinity: Original Sin 2. Its unparalleled wealth of gameplay choices, tactical depth, and inventive multiplayer cement its place at the pinnacle of RPG excellence. If you're a Witcher fan ready to embark on a new quest, Divinity: Original Sin 2 is your grail.